Toni's family thought maybe she took a wrong turn and drove into a nearby lake on accident. After searching the lake, Toni's car was not found.
There are hardly any clues in Toni's case. Her license plate was electronically recorded in Camden, NJ shortly after she disappeared.
In January 2013, an anonymous letter was sent to police. It was written on a yellow legal pad, and stated, "What happened to (Toni), I don't really know. All I know is she had a run-in with the police and I was paid much-needed cash to get the car to a shop in Boston.The writer claims to have helped ditch Sharpless’ car in Boston in 2009 for about $5,000 at the request of a friend. "I came back to Camden a day later and (the friend) told me that the car was not stolen, but missing. He said a friend of his, a cop in Camden, got into a fight with a girl, she died and he needed to get the car out of Jersey," the letter stated. The writer included the VIN of Toni's car also.
After Toni disappeared, her cell phone and bank account were never accessed again.
It is speculated that Toni got into drugs in Camden, and possibly involved in sex trafficking. This is a possibility, as Toni was an attractive woman and struggled with a mental disorder.
Toni Lee Sharpless is still missing today.
For more information, please read